top of page

A Constant Drumbeat' of Racial Essentialism

Zack De Piero taught writing for four years in the English department at Penn State's Abington campus.

Conor Friedersdorf

The Atlantic

January 29, 2024

Viewpoint Detected:

Moderate Left

Fallacies Detected:

Composition/Division Fallacy, Appeal to Emotion, False Dilemma, Straw Man, Biased Language, Hasty Generalization

credAIble Evaluation:

The article discusses a lawsuit filed by Zack De Piero against Penn State, alleging discrimination and a hostile work environment due to its diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) initiatives. It highlights the complexity and divisiveness of DEI efforts within academia, framing the lawsuit as a significant moment that could influence how such initiatives are perceived and implemented nationwide. The article leans moderately left, acknowledging the importance of DEI while scrutinizing its execution, suggesting that some approaches may inadvertently foster discrimination. The use of emotionally charged language and examples, alongside generalizations about DEI programs, points to underlying biases. It raises valid concerns about the potential for DEI efforts to become counterproductive when not carefully managed, but does so in a way that simplifies a nuanced issue, at times presenting a false dilemma between combating racism and promoting an inclusive environment. The narrative subtly employs biased language and straw man fallacies, critiquing the most extreme aspects of DEI initiatives rather than their core principles or more balanced implementations.

bottom of page