top of page

America's restrictive turn on abortion pushes against a regional -- and democratic -- trend

This month, legislators in Guatemala approved a draconian law ordering up to 10 years in prison for women who have abortions.

Frida Ghitis

Wahington Post

March 19, 2022

Viewpoint Detected:

Moderate Left

Fallacies Detected:

Appeal to Emotion, Slippery Slope, Biased Language

credAIble Evaluation:

The article discusses recent legislative actions in Latin America concerning abortion laws, highlighting a trend towards liberalization and contrasting this with the situation in the United States. It mentions Guatemala's reversal of a harsh anti-abortion law, Colombia's Supreme Court ruling to legalize abortion up to the 24th week, and similar movements in Mexico and Argentina as part of a broader "green tide" advocating for reproductive rights. This regional shift is juxtaposed with the tightening of abortion laws in the U.S., including challenges to Roe v. Wade, the Texas six-week ban, and restrictions in other states. The narrative employs an appeal to emotion, using terms like "draconian" to describe anti-abortion laws and mentioning the plight of women affected by restrictive policies. It suggests a slippery slope in the U.S., where the trend appears to be moving away from reproductive freedoms. The language used carries a bias towards supporting abortion rights, framing the issue within the context of human rights and discrimination against poor women. The piece positions the United States as an outlier not only in its region but also among democracies worldwide, implying a dissonance between its self-perception as a beacon of freedom and its actions regarding abortion rights.

bottom of page