top of page

Harvard, M.I.T. and Systemic Antisemitism

This Monday, March 11, roughly 200 Jewish students and supporters marched through the campus of the University of California, Berkeley, and it was newsworthy that they were not attacked.

David French

New York Times

March 14, 2024

Viewpoint Detected:


Fallacies Detected:

Appeal to Emotion, Biased Language, False Dilemma, Slippery Slope

credAIble Evaluation:

This analysis deeply explores the alarming prevalence of systemic antisemitism on elite college campuses, underpinned by detailed legal complaints against Harvard and MIT. The narrative employs an Appeal to Emotion by vividly recounting incidents of violence, intimidation, and fear experienced by Jewish students, effectively drawing readers into the gravity of the situation. Biased Language is evident in the characterization of universities' responses and the broader tolerance for antisemitic behaviors compared to other forms of offensive conduct, suggesting a specific neglect of Jewish students' safety and rights. A False Dilemma is presented, indicating that the only options are either to allow unchecked antisemitism under the guise of free speech or to impose strict sanctions against it, disregarding potential middle-ground solutions that respect free speech while protecting students from harassment. The argument also traverses a Slippery Slope by implying that failing to address these issues could lead to an erosion of safety and inclusivity for Jewish individuals across America, potentially reverting to "ancient bigotries." The piece calls for urgent action to combat this deeply ingrained bias, suggesting that universities' failure to protect Jewish students from harassment and discrimination not only violates their moral obligations but also legal requirements under Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. It underlines the critical need for equitable treatment and safety for all students, invoking America's foundational values of liberty and justice to advocate for a society where no individual, Jewish or otherwise, should live in fear because of their identity.

bottom of page