How Austin Metcalf’s accused killer is raking in cash for his legal defense — as sick conspiracy theories about victim spread ‘hate, fear and division’

The article attempts to cover a tragic and controversial legal case, but it also reflects the powerful role of misinformation and emotional manipulation in shaping public discourse. While quoting police and legal sources, it highlights fallacious narratives circulating online — such as false claims about the victim’s behavior and fabricated evidence — which constitute Straw Man and False Cause fallacies. Emotional appeals are evident in donor comments and biblical citations that attempt to morally exonerate Karmelo before trial. Use of Biased Language portrays both families and communities in an emotionally charged light. Misinformation and fake fundraising pages are Genetic Fallacies and Red Herrings distracting from the central facts of the case.