top of page

The Academy at the Crossroads

UPenn president Liz Magill would not have been forced to resign had donors and alumni not been organizing against her for two months.

Heather Mac Donald

City Journal

December 13, 2023

Viewpoint Detected:

Strong Right

Fallacies Detected:

Straw Man, Ad Hominem, Biased Language, False Dilemma, Hasty Generalization, Slippery Slope

credAIble Evaluation:

The article demonstrates a strong right-leaning bias, primarily through its criticism of progressive ideologies and policies in higher education. It uses straw man arguments by oversimplifying and misrepresenting the positions of those it criticizes, notably in its portrayal of university policies and donor reactions. Ad hominem attacks are present, targeting specific individuals and groups for their perceived roles in the events described. The language used is heavily biased, framing progressive educational policies and actions in a consistently negative light. The article presents a false dilemma, suggesting that the only way to rectify perceived issues in higher education is through the extreme measures proposed by the donors. Hasty generalizations are made about the motives and actions of university administrators, faculty, and students, without sufficient evidence for such broad claims. The piece also suggests a slippery slope, implying that the continuation of current trends in higher education will lead to severe and widespread negative outcomes. Overall, the narrative lacks balance, focusing on criticizing one side of the debate while not adequately considering alternative perspectives or the complexities of university governance and academic freedom.

bottom of page