top of page

Trump border czar fires back at AOC over DOJ probe remarks: ‘Why doesn’t she pass some legislation?’

Charles Creitz, Elizabeth Elkind,

The New York Post

May 15, 2025

Viewpoint Detected:

Strong

Fallacies Detected:

Ad Hominem, Appeal to Emotion, Red Herring, False Cause, Straw Man

credAIble Evaluation:

Tom Homan’s statements deflect from substantive legal issues with Ad Hominem attacks on Rep. Ocasio-Cortez’s work ethic and purpose. His claim that Trump has improved the country and arrested more criminals introduces a False Cause, linking unrelated events without evidence. Appeal to Emotion is employed via ridicule and mockery (“I’m extremely intimidated”), designed to delegitimize rather than engage. The exchange also uses a Straw Man by misrepresenting AOC’s advocacy as obstruction or incitement. Finally, a Red Herring shifts attention from the legality of her actions to her character and hypothetical partisan threats. The argument prioritizes rhetoric over reasoning.

Thanks for submitting to credAIble!

bottom of page